Difference between revisions of "PHDBA279S (Spring 2011)"

From edegan.com
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Ed
imported>Ed
 
(7 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 9: Line 9:
  
 
The class is as follows:
 
The class is as follows:
−
*Thursdays from '''1pm to 3pm''' - This time slot is '''[http://osoc.berkeley.edu/OSOC/osoc?y=14&p_term=SP&p_deptname=Business+Administration+Doctoral+Program&p_classif=--+Choose+a+Course+Classification+--&p_presuf=--+Choose+a+Course+Prefix%2fSuffix+--&x=60 as posted in the online schedule] and may be open to debate'''.
+
*Thursdays from '''12:30pm to 2pm'''.
 
*In F555
 
*In F555
 
*With Steve Tadelis
 
*With Steve Tadelis
Line 16: Line 16:
 
*By tradition/convention the presenter brings "classy" chocolate for all to share
 
*By tradition/convention the presenter brings "classy" chocolate for all to share
  
−
==Priority for Scheduling==
+
==Who is Presenting==
  
−
The order of priority for scheduling is:
+
A list of [[BPP Students | all BPP students is here]]. Note that there are 14 current BPP students in years 2 through 6, and 14 slots. However, Job Market candidates, other than Dylan, will be sharing a slot, or a slot will be used for the job market recap.  
−
*Sixth Years (Justin)
 
−
*Fifth Years
 
−
*Fourth Years
 
−
*Third Years
 
−
*Second Years
 
−
 
 
−
Please add yourself (first name only will do) in to any date that you would like to present, noting that the priority above applies. Within years it is first-come-first-served (yes there is a history function to check!). During the first class we will have a clearance. But if you feel sure that you have a date (i.e. because you are a sixth year, or fifth year and Justin has already chosen, or all fifth years have decided and you are a fourth year, and so on by induction) you can turn your name '''bold'''. A list of [[BPP Students | all BPP students is here]]. Note that there are 14 current BPP students in years 2 through 6, and 14 slots (yeah!).  
 
  
 
==Schedule of Classes==
 
==Schedule of Classes==
  
−
'''THIS SCHEDULE IS CURRENTLY BEING CONTESTED - PLEASE SEE BELOW'''
+
'''THIS SCHEDULE IS FINAL AND WAS AGREED WITH STEVE'''
  
−
*Thurs 20th January -
+
*Thurs 20th January - '''No Class'''
−
*Thurs 27th January -  
+
*Thurs 27th January - '''No Class'''
−
*Thurs 3rd February - '''Orie'''
+
*Thurs 3rd February - '''Orie'''  
−
*Thurs 10th February - Lucy
+
*Thurs 10th February - '''Tarek'''
−
*Thurs 17th February - Tarek
+
*Thurs 17th February - '''Neil'''
−
*Thurs 24th February - Tarek
+
*Thurs 24th February - '''Ed'''
−
*Thurs 3rd March - '''Vito''' Lucy
+
*Thurs 3rd March - '''Vito'''
 
*Thurs 10th March - '''Dylan'''
 
*Thurs 10th March - '''Dylan'''
 
*Thurs 17th March - '''Pablo'''
 
*Thurs 17th March - '''Pablo'''
Line 43: Line 36:
 
*Thurs 31st March - '''Amy'''
 
*Thurs 31st March - '''Amy'''
 
*Thurs 7th April - '''Sharat'''
 
*Thurs 7th April - '''Sharat'''
−
*Thurs 14th April - '''Neil''',Ed, Bo
+
*Thurs 14th April - '''Bo'''
−
*Thurs 21st April - '''Justin'''
+
*Thurs 21st April - '''Lucy'''
−
*Thurs 28th April - '''Sharon'''
+
*Thurs 28th April - '''Job Market Recap (or 5th/6th years)'''
−
 
 
−
If job market candidates don't need a slot then please "sign" below, so we can still clear the priority sorting:
 
−
*I don't need a slot - '''Bryan'''
 
−
 
 
−
==Proposed New Institutions==
 
−
 
 
−
The schedule above is what happened using by senority, first-come-first-served system. This schedule seems to be socially sub-optimal (i.e. it doesn't maximize social welfare). Orie sent an email noting this and proposing a new system:
 
−
 
 
−
I’d like to point out that we have some issues with the schedule.
 
−
For example, that the 2nd years are presenting very early in the semester after having
 
−
presented late in the fall, and almost everyone else is in pure rank order.
 
−
After some discussion here is what I propose for norms so that the online date
 
−
selection matches better what used to happen in the scheduling meeting.
 
−
 
−
In general, everyone should pick by seniority, but with the following conditions:
 
−
 
 
−
'''For the Spring:'''
 
−
-Job market candidates get spots only after everyone else has chosen.
 
−
-Those with specific plans for orals in the spring have first priority
 
−
-2nd years don’t get stuck early in the spring after presenting late in the fall.
 
−
 
 
−
'''For the Fall:'''
 
−
-3rd years (who have just completed 2nd year papers) present early
 
−
-2nd years each get half a slot, and present relatively late in the semester
 
−
-Job market candidates get priority, but are encouraged to present early in the
 
−
semester, especially before their OEW slots and other outside presentations.
 
−
 
−
These are still subject to gaming, but I hope we would all stick to the spirit of these.
 
−
 
 
−
I (Ed) feel that the easiest way to '''operationalize Orie's proposal''' is to change the senority order to the following:
 
−
'''Fall Term'''
 
−
#Job Market Candidates
 
−
#Second Years as a group for a single slot
 
−
#By Senority (with the third years last)
 
  
−
'''Spring Term'''
+
==New Institutions==
−
#Those taking their orals
 
−
#2nd Years
 
−
#By senority (except for job market candidates)
 
−
#Job Market Candidates
 
  
−
'''An alternative''' that should also work, and which still affords more seniority to rank is:
+
Following a BPP student group meeting with Steve Tadelis, we have collectively (and with the faculty) agreed a new institution for the presentation order at the Student Seminar. This is detailed here:
−
*Each term is broken into a first half and a second half.
+
*[[PHDBA279S Presentation Institutions]]
−
*There are two rounds followed by a clearance. You may choose only once before the clearance.
+
*[[BPP Student Institutions]]
−
*In the first round senority is by program order (6th year -> 2nd year), but you may choose only from the first half of the slots (or wait until the next round).
 
−
*In the second round both halfs are open and the senority is as in Ed's proposal above.
 
  
−
'''The status quo''' is not the senority system that we have used to date on the wiki. Rather, it is what ever schedule Steve (or whomever is running the seminar) would impose on us.
+
==Discussion==
  
−
As always, please feel free to discuss this on the [[Talk:PHDBA279S_(Spring_2011) | Discussion Page]].
+
As always, please feel free to discuss anything on the [[Talk:PHDBA279S_(Spring_2011) | Discussion Page]].

Latest revision as of 16:48, 30 January 2011

PHDBA279S is the PhD in BPP Research Seminar, generally known as the BPP Student Seminar. It is a weekly seminar where students present their research to other students in the group. This is a required seminar for BPP students in the 2nd year and above. For Spring 2011 Steve Tadelis will be the supervising faculty member.

There is an "official version" of this page, that the faculty can access. It is not important to keep the two syncronized. We can post the "final" results of the exploration that will take place on this page to that page once we are done.

Class Details

The class is as follows:

  • Thursdays from 12:30pm to 2pm.
  • In F555
  • With Steve Tadelis
  • Starting 20th January (Instruction formally begins Tuesday January 18th) and ending April 28th (classes formally end Friday April 29th)
  • Thurs 24th March is listed in the Official Academic Calendar as Spring Break
  • By tradition/convention the presenter brings "classy" chocolate for all to share

Who is Presenting

A list of all BPP students is here. Note that there are 14 current BPP students in years 2 through 6, and 14 slots. However, Job Market candidates, other than Dylan, will be sharing a slot, or a slot will be used for the job market recap.

Schedule of Classes

THIS SCHEDULE IS FINAL AND WAS AGREED WITH STEVE

  • Thurs 20th January - No Class
  • Thurs 27th January - No Class
  • Thurs 3rd February - Orie
  • Thurs 10th February - Tarek
  • Thurs 17th February - Neil
  • Thurs 24th February - Ed
  • Thurs 3rd March - Vito
  • Thurs 10th March - Dylan
  • Thurs 17th March - Pablo
  • Thurs 24th March - SPRING BREAK
  • Thurs 31st March - Amy
  • Thurs 7th April - Sharat
  • Thurs 14th April - Bo
  • Thurs 21st April - Lucy
  • Thurs 28th April - Job Market Recap (or 5th/6th years)

New Institutions

Following a BPP student group meeting with Steve Tadelis, we have collectively (and with the faculty) agreed a new institution for the presentation order at the Student Seminar. This is detailed here:

Discussion

As always, please feel free to discuss anything on the Discussion Page.

Retrieved from "http://www.edegan.com/mediawiki/index.php?title=PHDBA279S_(Spring_2011)&oldid=34010"