Tag: Entrepreneurship

Categories
McNair Center Weekly Roundup

Entrepreneurship Weekly Roundup: 12/02/2016

Weekly Roundup is a McNair Center series compiling and summarizing the week’s most important Entrepreneurship and Innovation news.

Here is what you need to know about entrepreneurship this week:

Keep Austin Entrepreneurial

Eliza Martin, Research Assistant, McNair Center for Entrepreneurship and Innovation

In 2016, Austin was ranked as the number one U.S. city for startup activity by the Kauffman Foundation. Austin’s entrepreneurial ecosystem began in the 1970s and 1980s, and was originally focused on computer and semiconductor manufacturing.

Austin’s “Silicon Hills” has diversified into “more than the computer chip and semiconductor industry that first enabled its growth.” The annual South by Southwest Festival draws thousands of tech startups to the city and provides excellent networking opportunities for entrepreneurs. The University of Texas at Austin adds thousands of skilled employees to the city’s labor force each year. Additionally, UT Austin’s boasts the Austin Technology Incubator, a startup-focused incubator run by the university’s IC2 Institute.

Austin provides entrepreneurs with supportive policy infrastructure, skilled and energetic laborers and access to valuable mentorship opportunities. If efforts to grow Austin’s economy continue on their current path, the city will be well poised to solidify its presence as a thriving entrepreneurial ecosystem.

Overtime Rules in Limbo: What Businesses Should Do Now

Jeremy Quittner, Reporter, Fortune

Last week, a federal judge judge in Texas granted a preliminary injunction against the Department of Labor’s new overtime rules that were set to go into effect on December 1st. The new overtime rules would have increased the threshold salary for overtime workers to $47,476 from $23,600. Many small business owners, acting in preparation for the new rule, made the difficult financial decision to switch salaried workers to hourly status.

The preliminary injunction still must go through an additional 60 day period of court hearings before it becomes an official injunction. Additionally, the Obama administration’s Department of Labor could still appeal the judge’s decision to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th circuit. It is not yet clear if the administration will challenge the judge’s decision. Even if the decision is appealed, success on appeal is doubtful; in the court’s recent history, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit has tended to challenge the Obama administration.

McNair Center’s Catherine Kirby previously examined the effects of new overtime labor laws on small businesses in her blog post Small Business and Overtime Regulation.

One simple way billionaire investor Peter Thiel identifies game-changing startups

Eugene Kim, Reporter, Business Insider

Peter Thiel, serial VC investor and founder of PayPal, is known for his profitable investments in successful billion dollar startups, such as Facebook, Palantir, Stripe and SoFi. Business Insider’s Kim reports possible insights into Thiel’s keen eye for return on investment.

In an interview at VC firm Khosla Ventures’ KV CEO Summit, Thiel recently said, “I think in some ways the really good companies often couldn’t even be articulated…we didn’t quite have the right words. Or maybe they were articulated but were articulated in terms of categories that were actually misleading.” Thiel cautioned investors away from startups that rely on buzzwords, such as big data or cloud computing, in their pitches. Thiel said, “…when you hear those words, you need to think fraud and run away as fast as you can. It’s like a tell that you’re bluffing, that there’s nothing unique about the business.”

White House expands platforms for inclusive entrepreneurship

Kate Conger, Reporter, TechCrunch

The White House recently announced “new and expanded plans to improve diversity and inclusion within the startup economy.” The plans are focused on promoting diversity in higher education, investment and entrepreneurship. The initiatives reflect the Obama Administration’s commitment to improving minority representation in universities, investment firms and tech companies. By focusing the initiatives within the private sector, these efforts will hopefully continue after his departure from office.

More than 200 universities, all members of The American Society for Engineering Education, have signed a pledge to promote diversity in their engineering programs. Additionally, more than 30 VC firms and accelerators signed a pledge to diversify access to seed and early stage capital for underrepresented entrepreneurs and reveal information regarding their portfolios’ diversity. Furthermore, 46 tech companies, including Xerox, have joined the Tech Inclusion Pledge, demonstrating a commitment to publicly publish recruitment goals and diversity metrics.

Tom Kalil, deputy director for technology and innovation at the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy, reportedly told TechCrunch there is existing data that indicates diverse firms are more diverse are more likely to be successful. According to Kalil, “A lot of innovation comes from diversity, people with different backgrounds.”

Data science startup Civis Analytics raises $22 million

Ken Yeung, Contributor, VentureBeat

Civis Analytics recently announced that it bagged $22 million in its latest Series A funding round. Civis Analytics was born out of President Obama’s 2012 reelection campaign. Though originally focused on political campaigns, the data science company’s cloud-based platform provides data analytics tools and methodologies  to organizations focused in areas such as health care, media and education. Since its inception, the startup has relied on revenues, rather than funding, to support its operations. However, the startup announced its recent funding will go toward hiring more engineers and data scientists.

Civis Analytics CEO, Dan Wagner states the importance of data analysis to business success: “Everyone knows that they need to be using data, but most don’t know where to start. Or, if they are using data, they aren’t necessarily asking and answering the right questions.”

Stripe Investment Makes Cofounder The World’s Youngest Self-Made Billionaire

Ryan Mac, Reporter, Forbes

Brothers Patrick and John Collison are cofounders of San Francisco-based startup Stripe. Stripe is a tech company that enables private individuals and companies to engage in transactions via the internet and on mobile apps. MIT and Harvard dropouts, respectively, Patrick and John Collison recently joined the ranks of the world’s youngest self-made billionaires. Stripe recently announced a successful funding round, which doubled the startup’s valuation to $9.2 billion. CapitalG and General Catalyst Partners jointly invested $150 million in Stripe during its latest funding round.

Despite their early success, the Collision brothers are still hungry for more; Patrick Collison told Forbes in January of 2014 that, “Heartening as the success to date has been, we are so early in accomplishing the goals that we set out for ourselves. If anyone here believes that Stripe has already made it, that would be hugely problematic for us.”

QA with Kauffman’s Victor Hwang on entrepreneurship in the heartland

Ryan Pendell, Contributor, Silicon Prairie News

Victor Hwang, Vice President of Kauffman Foundation, and Phil Wickham, Executive Chairman of Kauffman Fellows set out on a road trip through America’s Midwest earlier this month to “take the pulse of entrepreneurship in America’s “middle.” Despite a nationwide political narrative that depicts the Midwest in a state of slumping stagnation, caught between booming coastal economies, Hwang and Wickham report that Midwestern entrepreneurs are actively seeking out business solutions to improve the quality of life within their communities. Since the benefits of the tech boom have been focused on the coasts, Hwang and Wickham cite the biggest challenges to Midwestern entrepreneurs as access to capital.

According to Hwang, the need to build infrastructure and capital should be considered both a challenge and an opportunity for Midwestern entrepreneurs going forward. Hwang expressed optimism for the future of the Midwestern economy, claiming that the region’s culture of “civic mindedness, that willingness to pitch in, that willingness to take risks and help others reach their ambitions” is still alive.

Policy Changes Needed to Unlock Employment and Entrepreneurial Opportunity for 100 Million Americans with Criminal Records, Kauffman Research Shows

Ewing Marion Kauffman Foundation

According to a report recently published by the Kauffman Foundation, rethinking America’s “occupational licensing policy could counter recidivism, encourage entrepreneurship and boost the American economy.” Currently, occupational licensing requirements prevent individuals with a criminal history from securing licenses that could open the door to financial stability and self-sufficiency. Many occupations that require occupational licenses are on low-skilled and high-skilled professions; increased labor participation, productivity and entrepreneurship by released inmates within these fields could therefore produce benefits for the overall economy. According to the Kauffman Foundation’s study, over 60 percent of inmates released each year from state or federal prison are still unemployed after one year of their release.

The Kauffman Foundation’s Emily Fetsch notes that the high levels of recidivism and unemployment among ex-convicts indicate a fundamental issue with the country’s occupational licensing policy: “Hundreds of professions that require occupational licenses could provide paths to economic independence for those formerly incarcerated, except for the fact that their criminal histories alone may ban them from receiving licenses, even if their convictions had no relevancy to the job.”

Fetsch recommends reforms to occupational licensing policy that would exclude only criminal defendants who pose a a public threat or when convictions are recent and relevant to the context of an occupation. Additionally, Fetsch proposes offering the formerly incarcerated opportunities to earn rehabilitation or restoration certificates, thereby preventing inmates from automatic disqualification for consideration of occupational licenses solely on the basis of their arrest. Lastly, Fetsch contemplates disposing of occupational licensing requirements altogether, expressing skepticism for the regulation’s effects in promoting public safety and health.

An Incubator for (Former) Drug Dealers

Maura Ewing, Reporter, Bloomberg

“Amid calls for more job training, less automatic background searching and other changes that would make it easier for ex-felons to become employees” Bloomberg’s Ewing reports on an alternative perspective solution on the fight to curb recidivism and unemployment  among the formerly incarcerated: encouraging them to start their own businesses.

The public and private sphere should continue to push programs that support formerly incarcerated individuals, as well as tackle the structural problems that face these prisoners as they re-enter society. However, Ewing asserts that more emphasis should be placed on the potential returns on fostering entrepreneurship among this commonly dismissed population.

Defy Ventures, a nonprofit incubator based in New York, certainly achieved success in this regard by transforming ex-convicts into entrepreneurs. Over the past six years, Defy Ventures has trained upwards of 500 released felons and successfully incubated over 150 companies. What’s more, the recidivism rate among the incubator’s alumni within five years post release is an astonishing 3 percent, compared to the national average of 76 percent. Defy Venture’s efficacy in curbing recidivism rates suggests that future initiatives to support released prisoners should be focused on entrepreneurship.

Ewing’s article tells the story of another incubator underway in Hartford. The incubator, TRAP House, focuses on supporting former drug dealers as they start new, legal companies. The incubator’s name makes a clever reference to slang for drug-stash locations and is “short for transforming, reinvesting and prospering.”

Happy Holidays from the McNair Center for Entrepreneurship and Innovation. The Entrepreneurship Weekly Roundup will return in January.

Categories
McNair Center Startup Ecosystems

Keep Austin Entrepreneurial

Austin, Texas

Ranked number one for startup activity in the last two years by the Kauffman Foundation, Austin, Texas is one of the strongest emerging entrepreneurship ecosystems in the United States. Austin’s history of entrepreneurship and supportive government has facilitated Austin’s emergence as an entrepreneurial ecosystem.

Austin’s History of Entrepreneurship

During the 1970s and 1980s, Austin’s entrepreneurial ecosystem focused on computer and semiconductor manufacturing. Efforts by the Austin Chamber of Commerce, such as low mortgage rates for relocating staff and tax incentives, fueled the move of several major companies to Austin: IBM in 1967, Texas Instruments in 1969 and Motorola in 1974. A doubling in student attendance at the University of Texas in the early 1970s increased the educated workforce in the region.

The selection of Austin as the home of the Microelectronic Computer Corporation (MCC) in 1982 accelerated this concentration of high-tech companies. Facing fierce competition from Japan’s Fifth Generation Project, major U.S. companies banded together and created MCC, one of the largest computer research companies at the time. MCC chose Austin instead of Silicon Valley and Route 128 because the University of Texas offered MCC a subsidized lease and the Chamber of Commerce facilitated low-cost loans and reduced mortgage rates for staff moving to Austin.

Austin, Texas
Austin, Texas

Initially, the Austin ecosystem was primarily large businesses, such as IBM and Texas Instruments. This focus changed after the oil slump and savings and loan crises of the late 1980s and early 1990s crippled the Texas economy. Austin was not spared. It had one of the highest commercial real estate vacancy rates in the country and companies laid off large numbers of employees.

In response, the University of Texas formed the Austin Technology Incubator (ATI) in 1989 to jumpstart the local economy through high-tech startups with high-growth potential. In 1989, Greg Kozmetsky, the brain behind ATI, founded Austin’s first angel network, the Capital Network. These initiatives provided a foundation for growth during the 1990s dot-com boom. Austin companies such as Garden.com, an online gardening shop that raised $50 million in venture capital, and DrKoop.com, an “Internet-based consumer health-care network,” that was worth more than $1 billion, found success in Austin.

In 2000, thirty Austin venture capitalists invested over $2 billion in entrepreneurship ventures. The subsequent burst of the dot-com bubble in the early 2000s hurt Austin. After the 2001-2003 economic downturn, the region experienced major industrial restructuring and a renewal of entrepreneurship.

In 2003, the business community raised $11 million for Opportunity Austin, an economic development program. Opportunity Austin focused on recruiting new businesses, marketing Austin effectively and stimulating entrepreneurship and emerging technology sectors.

Less than five years after the last economic downturn, the Great Recession of 2008 set back many new Austin businesses. While venture capital and small business creation are not at the level they were during the dot-com boom, the rate of startup growth is currently 81.23 percent.

Entrepreneurship in Austin Now

Austin is experiencing yet another entrepreneurship boom. Austin now has the supportive policy structure, mentors and sector diversification required to finally establish a lasting ecosystem.

Austin’s cultural support of local businesses and responsive state and local government policies are fueling its start-up growth. The absence of state income tax incentivizes young professionals to work and settle in Texas. The local Austin government provides services for people considering starting a business such as BizAid Business Orientation and Small Business Program. The Entrepreneur Center of Austin and the Indus Entrepreneurs of Austin specifically provide support for start-ups. The University of Texas’ Herb Kelleher Center for Entrepreneurship, Growth and Renewal connects Austin entrepreneurs with resources.

As a result of Austin’s strong history of entrepreneurship, mentorship opportunities for nascent entrepreneurs are readily available. Austin companies, such as Dell, offer mentorship and accelerator programs. Entrepreneurial hubs, such as Tech Ranch Austin and Capital Factory, serve as an intersection between Austin incubators, accelerators, coworking spaces and also offer mentorship programs for entrepreneurs.

While known as “Silicon Hills,” Austin’s entrepreneurship economy is much more diversified than the computer chip and semiconductor industry that first enabled its growth. According to a 2015 Austin Technology Council report, approximately 14 percent of the $22.3 billion value of Austin’s tech companies came from semiconductors. Computer and peripheral equipment contributed 31 percent. Both Austin-born and transplanted companies focus on the bioscience, energy, clean-technology, water and IT/wireless industries. Austin has an extremely strong tech-focused entrepreneurship industry, but it also has successful media, education and social and craft/lifestyle ventures.

Venture Capital in Texas and Austin

Texas’ venture capital investment has decreased by 19 percent over the past ten years. To maintain a healthy entrepreneurship ecosystem, it is imperative that venture capital investment increases in the coming years.

Austin’s ecosystem lacks capital. In 2014, Austin saw 99 venture capital deals worth $739 million. In contrast, Silicon Valley saw 1,333 deals worth more than $27 billion. While there is no shortage of capital in Texas, there is a lack of capital access, information and government support. The majority of Texas capital is invested in oil, gas and real estate. These are considered by many to be less risky than entrepreneurship ventures. However, as oil prices fall, Texans should consider trying to raise growth and investing in entrepreneurial ventures.

Austin’s most prominent venture capital fund, Austin Ventures, closed in 2015. Phil Siegel and David Lack left to form Tritium Partners to provide capital for startups in Austin. Its first fund of $309 million is a fraction of the $900 million Austin Ventures raised at its peak. Silverton Partners and S3 Ventures have tried to fill the void left by Austin Ventures. However, none of these Austin venture capital funds have the capital or assets that Austin Ventures had.

Entrepreneurial Resources in Austin

Austin has a plethora of resources for entrepreneurs. The annual South by Southwest Festival provides networking opportunities. Companies are taking advantage of the 100,000 college students that graduate each year in the greater Austin area. The University of Texas at Austin boasts the Austin Technology Incubator under the IC² Institute, which has raised almost $700 million in investor capital to achieve this goal. Additionally, the Central Texas Angel Network provides capital and mentorship support for entrepreneurs in the Central Texas region.

What Starts in Austin, Changes the World

Austin’s entrepreneurial ecosystem is moving towards national recognition. Favor, a food delivery app, is an alumni of ATI and backed by Austin’s S3 Ventures and Silverton Partners. HomeAway, an Austin based online rental marketplace, was established in 2005 and acquired by Expedia for $3.9 billion in 2015. In the upcoming years, it is critical that capital investment continues to support new ventures such as Favor and HomeAway. Austin’s ecosystem has the policy, talent and mentorship to be successful, but private and public efforts must continue to ensure its success.

Categories
McNair Center Rice Entrepreneurs

Spotlight on Rice Entrepreneurs: An Outlet for Owlets

Owlet

An Outlet for Owlets: New Opportunities for Entrepreneurship and Innovation at Rice

On November 15, the Princeton Review ranked Rice University’s Jones Graduate School of Business third in the top graduate programs for entrepreneurship. For the past eight years, the Jones School’s entrepreneurship program has ranked in the top 10 in the nation. In addition to the Jones School’s ongoing success, several programs focus on undergraduate entrepreneurship and innovation. Recently launched programs promote entrepreneurship through student-led efforts and university-sponsored initiatives.

Consolidating student-led efforts

At the end of Spring 2016, two undergraduate entrepreneurship clubs, Rice Launch (led by Ben Herndon-Miller and Jake Nyquist) and Rice Conversations (led by Iris Huang and Doria Du), merged to form the Rice Entrepreneurship Club. The new club organizes a variety of events, including casual lunch conversations with entrepreneurs, pitch practices and mentor workshops.

Working closely with the Rice Alliance for Technology and Entrepreneurship and the Rice Entrepreneurship Initiative, the club shares opportunities and resources to encourage greater student collaboration. “I think the merge empowered the student leaders from both clubs to better serve student entrepreneurs at Rice,” said Iris Huang ’17, President of the Entrepreneurship Club. “With the substantial pool of combined resources, we are now able to put on more diverse programs and make a larger impact on the student population.”

Developing university-wide programs

In March 2016, Rice alumnus Frank Liu and his family gave $16.5 million to establish the Liu Idea Lab for Innovation and Entrepreneurship (Lilie). Headed by Dr. Yael Hochberg and Dr. Abby Larson, Lilie gives students access to the expertise and experiences that will help them launch their own enterprises.  Beginning next spring, courses offered through Lilie will encourage students to solve real-world problems while working with faculty and entrepreneurs. The Lilie New Entrepreneurs Grant will help incoming freshmen, starting with the Class of 2020, to fund their business ventures. Before matriculating, freshmen can apply for the $10,000 grant that funds the most creative and compelling business ideas.

Learning from entrepreneurs

Students listen to Scott Novich and Evan Dougal from Neosensory.
Students listen to Rice alumni Scott Novich and Evan Dougal from Neosensory.

Through casual conversations and more formal lectures, the Entrepreneurship Club and Lilie have emphasized directly connecting students with entrepreneurs.

On September 15, the club hosted NeoSensory, a startup co-founded by Scott Novich (Rice PhD ‘16). NeoSensory mathematically maps data streams with temporal characteristics to develop a vest that helps the deaf experience sound through touch. More than 70 attendees learned about the product development timeline, the investment process and university intellectual property licensing through the perspective of a startup.

More recently, on October 19, the Rice Entrepreneurship Club hosted a conversation with Shaan Puri from Monkey Inferno, a San Francisco incubator that turns Internet project ideas into successful businesses. Monkey Inferno sold Bebo to AOL for $850 million in 2008 and currently uses that money to fund new projects. Puri shared his perspectives on forming teams and overcoming conflict and disappointment. Additionally, he advised students to become “learning machines,” always looking to learn more and improve. To achieve momentum, Puri encouraged aspiring entrepreneurs to dedicate time each day to their business idea.

Shaan Puri from Monkey Inferno Skypes in from the Silicon Valley to speak with Rice undergraduates.
Shaan Puri from Monkey Inferno Skypes in from the Silicon Valley to speak with Rice undergraduates.

As part of the Lilie Lecture Series, Dr. Larson hosted an event with Samantha Snabes on October 26. Snabes served as the Entrepreneur-in-Residence and Strategist at NASA and founded re:3D, which makes 3D printing more accessible and scalable. During the lecture, Snabes spoke about taking big risks and establishing strong relationships with peers and mentors. When asked about the differences between the startup cultures of the Silicon Valley and cities in Texas, Snabes noted the benefits of being located in Texas while Austin, Dallas and Houston are growing as centers of startup activity.

Dr. Larson explains, “The Lectures bring together expertise and energies from across Rice and Houston. Each Lecture features the insights of an established entrepreneur or innovator on a question of interest to people working across a range of fields. The Lectures provide an opportunity for the exchange of questions and ideas between people who are innovating in many different contexts, and as such, often lead to new and shared insights.”

Engaging undergraduates in entrepreneurial activity

November 4-6, Rice and University of Houston students used this advice to develop technology ventures at 3 Day Startup. During the event, 45 students worked together in 9 teams at TMCx. Prototypes included an Airbnb-style app that connects travelers with locals for authentic meal experiences, a frictionless rental service for household tools and a marketplace where artists can cater to consumers’ requests for original artwork.

Maintaining momentum

The increased focus on entrepreneurship and innovation on campus is promising. This spark will attract more entrepreneurial talent and advance Rice University’s reputation as a hub for innovation.

Categories
Government and Policy McNair Center

Obama in the White House

Generating an Innovation Nation

The Obama administration’s policies toward small business and entrepreneurship have received mixed reactions. While Obama elevated the administrator of the Small Business Administration to a cabinet position and the SBA increased its lending to small businesses, some small business owners felt that the government bailed out big businesses at their expense after the 2008 financial crisis. Many small business owners are concerned about the effects of the Affordable Care Act.

Over the course of his presidency, Obama has played a part in connecting innovation with government. During his first term, he created the positions of Chief Technology Officer, Chief Data Scientist and Chief Performance Officer. In 2012, he began selecting entrepreneurs to work as Presidential Innovation Fellows within the federal government to make government more efficient, impactful and user-friendly.

Inspired by startups and music

Austin’s South by Southwest music and media festival inspired President Obama’s latest innovation project South by South Lawn (SXSL). Last month, the Obama administration invited community change-makers nominated by the public to attend SXSL. Innovators gathered at the White House to discuss how they use technology to advance areas like technology, food, art and collaboration.

On the technology panel “Fixing Real Problems,” innovators like Chris Redlitz (founding partner of Transmedia Capital and founder of The Last Mile), Jukay Hsu (founder of Coalition for Queens) and Nina Tandon (founder of EpiBone) addressed societal issues, including criminal justice reform, health care costs, access to higher education and job opportunities. Panelists emphasized the importance of understanding the impact of company growth on surrounding communities when planning for future endeavors. They emphasized the importance of creating inclusive access to the new opportunities brought about by societal transformation and technological change.

Focus on social entrepreneurship

With the Access Code program at Coalition for Queens, Jukay Hsu aims to increase economic opportunities in Queens. The program allows populations usually underrepresented in the technology field, like women and minorities, to gain the skills needed to enter the field. There are no upfront costs, but graduates of the program are expected to “pay it forward” by committing a percentage of their first two year’s salary toward funding future Access Code cohorts.

Chris Redlitz created The Last Mile in 2008 in an effort to reduce recidivism rates. For successful criminal justice reform, inmates need the skills to readjust to the outside world. To meet this need, the Last Mile started a six-month program for inmates to develop companies and pitch their ideas to the business community. In 2014, Redlitz created the first computer coding program in a United States prison, teaching HTML, JavaScript, CSS and Python.

Nod to for-profit entrepreneurship

At EpiBone, Nina Tandon provides patient-specific, customized bone grafts created from the patient’s own stem cells. Through this personalization of treatment, she aims to simplify procedures, provide more exact care and reduce the costs of post-surgery treatments. Each year, over 100,000 patients have bone-related surgeries in the United States alone. EpiBone could potentially increase access to these necessary operations through reducing costs and rehabilitation times.

Bringing innovation within government

Obama invited technology executives to join him in Washington to spearhead innovation in government. Former Google executive Megan Smith now serves as the United States Chief Technology Officer. Microsoft executive Kurt DelBene took a leave of absence in 2013 to help fix the problems with HealthCare.gov.

At SXSL, Presidential Innovation Fellows shared their projects to improve government efficiency at the “Startup in the White House” exhibit. Jacqueline Kazil’s GeoQ crowdsources geo-tagged photos to quicken disaster response. With the Green Button Initiative, John Teeter aims to help Americans understand and improve their energy use. The innovation company 18F has been developing NotAlone.Gov to provide students and schools with access to resources against sexual assault. Visitors saw how design and technology could potentially modernize the immigration system, improve veterans’ access to benefits and increase cancer patients’ access to clinical trials.

The first SXSL – and the last?

Although technology will not cure all of society’s ills, it has the potential to improve lives more quickly than any government institution could. Continuing initiatives that focus on creative solutions leads to a more widespread awareness of this potential. The federal government should focus on technology and innovation as integral contributors of growth.

Obama used SXSL to show innovation’s potential in policy solutions. Unfortunately, he made no mention of policy toward small businesses, particularly for-profit enterprises. Events like SXSL must also focus on policy that accelerates for-profit entrepreneurship that aid U.S. economy growth. There was no mention of how the federal government would incentivize entrepreneurship to strengthen the U.S. economy and maintain competitiveness in the global marketplace.

Whether through another South by South Lawn or the inclusion of innovators in policy solutions, the Trump administration should seek to make government more inclusive, transparent and effective. However, simply embracing startup culture and bringing entrepreneurs into government is far from enough. For entrepreneurship to play its full role, the U.S. needs policies that will actually help small businesses, not hinder. Only then will small enterprises and startups be able to take their place as drivers of economic growth.

Categories
McNair Center Weekly Roundup

Entrepreneurship Weekly Roundup: 11/11/2016

Weekly Roundup is a McNair Center series compiling and summarizing the week’s most important Innovation and Entrepreneurship news.

Here is what you need to know about entrepreneurship this week:

Small Businesses Can Expect Policy Changes Under Trump

The Associated Press

Entrepreneurs might expect policy shifts under a Trump presidency. Trump has released his plan for his first 100 days in office. However, much uncertainty over his policies and objectives remains. The battle over health care and immigration reform, taxes, regulation, the federal minimum wage, trade deals and federal contracts will be fought in a Republican-led congress that has not always agreed with the President-elect’s proposals.

David Levin, CEO of the American Sustainable Business Council, expressed the concern of many small business owners in the US: “What we don’t know is whether or not there is a sincere interest in supporting small and medium-size enterprises in this country — rebuilding Main Street, rebuilding manufacturing.”

With Election Over, Small Firms Look to Hire, Invest

Ruth Simon, Author, Wall Street Journal

With the uncertainty of the election partly resolved, some small business owners have said that they are ready to begin investing and hiring. According to a recent Vistage Worldwide poll of 380 small business owners, 49 percent of respondents said that the election of the outcome had improved their outlook for the economy. Nearly 20 percent stated that the election results encouraged them to increase their hiring or capital investment. Many point to the prospect of lower taxes and healthcare costs as sources for their optimism.

Not all business owners surveyed viewed the election’s outcome positively. 35 percent responded that their outlook for the economy had worsened. Roughly 20 percent planned on decreasing hiring and investment. Many are wary of Trump’s tough position on immigration, which could make the search for high-skilled workers more costly.

Black-Owned Businesses Face Credit Gap

Ruth Simon and Paul Overberg, Authors, The Wall Street Journal

According to data from the U.S. Census Bureau’s 2014 Survey of Entrepreneurs, black entrepreneurs are less likely to ask for capital when they need it. When they do ask, black entrepreneurs are not as likely to receive the full amount that they requested.

Black entrepreneurs in 2014 were three times more likely than white entrepreneurs to say that they were in need of additional financing but opted not to apply for it. Compared with 74 percent of white entrepreneurs, only 46 percent of black entrepreneurs received the full amount of funding that they had requested.

Simon cites challenges in access to capital and funding as obstacles for black entrepreneurs who are trying to grow their businesses. According to Alicia Robb, a senior fellow from the Ewing Marion Kauffman Foundation, “Across the board, blacks have higher denial rates, even after controlling for credit and wealth.”

How Lucrative Startups Can Avoid Disruption as They Grow

Jason Albanese, Contributor, Inc.

Jason Albanese, CEO and founder of Centric Digital, offers advice to startups looking to be the next Google or Facebook by redefining their industry. Revolutionary startups are often some of the most lucrative and successful in their field.

Market-shaking startups frequently fail to maximize their potential because market and operational disruptions often go hand in hand. Disruptive startups need to take time to grow at their own pace. Entrepreneurs cannot afford to rush the incubation period.

Most market ecosystems eventually find a new equilibrium; Airbnb and Uber recently experienced this within their industries. Albanese recommends that market-shifters foster and embrace change within company culture. Adaptivity, creativity and agility are instrumental in introducing and surviving a market disruption.

6 Strategic Business Practices For Freelance Entrepreneurs

Sam Cohen, Contributor, Huffington Post

The life of a freelance entrepreneur is uncertain and irregular. For example, daily operations lack the typical structure and comfort level that most industry jobs offer. On the other hand, self-employed entrepreneurs get to set their own work schedules and define the rules and best practices for their companies.

Despite the obvious discrepancy between freelance entrepreneurship and corporate culture, Sam Cohen recommends that entrepreneurs borrow business practices, such as building up cash reserves and establishing a performance review process, from bigger industry players.

Categories
McNair Center Rice Entrepreneurs

Rice Entrepreneurs: East-West Tea

This month the McNair Center is spotlighting Rice entrepreneurs to celebrate National Entrepreneurship Month. To kick off our series, we sat down with Andrew Maust, operations manager for East-West Tea.

East-West Tea

East-West Tea began in the spring of 2016 as a project in Scott Davis’s undergraduate marketing class. Dr. Davis, a post-doctoral fellow at the Jones Graduate School of Business, had students develop business strategies catering to underserved markets on campus. East-West Tea founder Drew Sutherland observed that students frequently went off campus to get boba tea and developed a plan to sell the beverage on campus. At the end of the semester, Sutherland and team members Tommy Bennett, David Cooper, Glenn Baginski and Leo Meiste implemented their plan. East-West launched retail operations on October 12.

Impact on the Rice Community

Andrew Maust joined the team last spring after going to several tea tastings. Since then, he’s climbed the ladder from kitchen worker to operations manager.

Maust describes the relationship East-West formed with Rice as symbiotic. “One of [East-West’s] core foundations is serving the Rice community. While what we do isn’t necessarily the easiest logistically, or makes us the most money on profit margins, we think it’s really important to serve the students and help them out in our endeavors.”

Maintaining a healthy relationship with Rice is a balancing act. Rice Housing and Dining provides East-West with shared kitchen space in Sammy’s. Without their own kitchen, East-West must “maintain operations but also not encroach on other people’s space.”

Maust says another challenge is running a small business and keeping up with schoolwork. He works 15-20 hours per week in the kitchen, which is “more hours than [he] takes in coursework”.

Advice to Rice Small Businesses

Maust also gave some advise to students who want to start their own business: “It has to be a labor of love. Your first goal shouldn’t be ‘Ooh, what can I do to make money?’ Because in order to build something that lasts and is high quality, it has to be something that you put in a lot of time and effort for. Money is great, but first and foremost you have to have that drive, that passion and put forth a great product.”

This resonates with advice Bob McNair gave students at an event at the Baker Institute on August 29th: Strive to create value and success will follow.

 

Categories
McNair Center Weekly Roundup

Entrepreneurship Weekly Roundup: 11/04/2016

Weekly Roundup is a McNair Center series compiling and summarizing the week’s most important Innovation and Entrepreneurship news.

Here is what you need to know about entrepreneurship this week:

Clocking In: Small Business and Overtime Regulation

Catherine Kirby, Research Assistant, McNair Center for Entrepreneurship and Innovation

In December, new US Department of Labor regulations on overtime pay eligibility will come into effect. These regulations will drastically increase the minimum salary for exemptions to overtime from $23,660 to $47,476. McNair Center’s Kirby discusses the pros and cons of the new overtime labor law. Her analysis offers insight on how to mitigate the increased costs to employers while promoting the benefits to low-income salaried workers.

  • The pros: Estimates forecast that the new regulations will create jobs in addition to providing compensation for employees working over 40 hours a week.
  • The cons: New regulations come with new costs for employers. Requiring employers to keep track of attendance and hours of more employees could be costly, especially for small businesses.
  • Policy recommendations: The Department of Labor could implement the regulations in phased increments rather than in one single shock. The government could lower small business taxes to reduce the regulatory burden.

Immigrants and Entrepreneurship

Dylan Dickens, Research Assistant, McNair Center for Entrepreneurship and Innovation

Many U.S. immigrants start businesses. Immigrant entrepreneurs are a diverse and growing group; immigrant entrepreneurs also have greatly varying levels of education. While immigrant entrepreneurs tend to live in larger states such as Texas and California, they compete for business in every U.S. state. The type of work immigrant entrepreneurs engage in is extremely varied. Partly as consequence of this, on average immigrant entrepreneurs outperform their native counterparts and are more skilled at finding market gaps by fulfilling unmet demand. Overall, McNair Center’s Dickens proposes that recent research supports the claim that immigration bolsters entrepreneurship in the US.

10 Marketplace KPIs That Matter

Andrei Brasoveanu, Author, Mattermark

Brasoveanu’s article summarizes the top ten Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) that every entrepreneur should closely monitor when building a market for their product.  Markets ultimately determine how every good and service in the economy is “discovered, priced and delivered.” KPIs, such as return on investment, growth and and burn rate, offer powerful and important insights for entrepreneurs. According to Brasoveanu, KPIs are effective and efficient marketplace metrics for getting startups on track to visualizing and contextualizing their success.

kpis

Scientists Working Outside Their Fields Are More Likely to Become Entrepreneurs

Brianna Stenard, Assistant Professor of Management and Entrepreneurship at the Stetson School of Business and Economics at Mercer University, Harvard Business Review

Highly skilled scientists and engineers are increasingly taking jobs that are outside of, or only slightly related, to their STEM degrees. Weak labor conditions in some STEM fields are partly to blame, but largely, the educational mismatch among scientists is voluntary. Stenard’s research indicates that many employees trained in the STEM fields take jobs outside of their field to acquire technical and managerial skills. Voluntarily mismatched scientists are nearly 50 percent more likely to become entrepreneurs.

Rather than bemoan an apparent oversupply of highly skilled scientists and engineers, Stenard recommends that policy makers implement initiatives that encourage technology entrepreneurship among these mismatched experts. Following a similar vein, Stenard proposes that universities should also consider adopting measures that equip STEM students with the “nontechnical skills…particularly valuable in entrepreneurship.”

And in startup news…

Airbnb’s Terms of Service just blocked a racial discrimination case

Russell Brandom, Reporter, The Verge

On Tuesday, Airbnb successfully blocked a class-action lawsuit that challenges the company’s platform on the basis of systematic racial discrimination. However, thanks to an arbitration clause in the company’s terms of service, the case will go through individual arbitration, and Airbnb will avoid a pricey and public lawsuit. The company recently added a nondiscrimination policy to its terms of service and has apparently taken measures to elimination discrimination from its network of hosts. When approached by the Verge on this issue, an Airbnb representative insisted that “Discrimination has no place in the Airbnb community.”

Palantir Prevails in Lawsuit Over U.S. Army Contracting Practices

Rolfe Winkler, Reporter, The Wall Street Journal

Another California-based startup recently won big in the courtroom, as data-mining software firm, Palantir, prevailed in its lawsuit against the US Army in the Court of Federal Claims. Palantir Technologies, Inc. ranks among Silicon’s Valley’s “most highly valued private companies” and was valued at $20 billion in a late funding round in 2015. The company specializes in big data analysis and offers its services to large commercial customers and government agencies within the intelligence community,. The court’s decision means that Palantir is now eligible for a federal contract that would award up to $200 million for work relating to the Army’s Distributed Common Ground System.
At the 2016 Wall Street Journal  Global Technology Conference, Palantir Chief Executive Alex Karp revealed that his company was positioned to go public.

GIF Site Giphy Is Valued at $600 Million

Rolfe Winkler, Reporter, The Wall Street Journal

Founded in 2013, Giphy, Inc. serves as a search engine and database for Graphical Interchange Format files(GIFs). GIFs are the “short, looping video files” that have most likely taken over your, or your teenager’s, Facebook News Feed. Thanks to Giphy, GIFs have surged in popularity and are now ubiquitous on social media sites and group-messaging platforms, such as Facebook messenger, Twitter, and Groupme. Giphy’s Chief Operating Officer Adam Leibsohn summarizes the company’s platform as a ”search engine…for the messenger generation.“
Giphy recently released an update stating that the company currently serves more than one billion GIFs per day, that are in turn watched by over 100 million users daily. This New York startup’s obvious popularity has not gone unnoticed by investors; Giphy raised $72 million in equity funding from venture capitalists during its most recent funding round, which brings the company’s  cash total to $150 million.

Categories
McNair Center Small Business

Small Business and Overtime Regulation

Clocking in: Small Business and Overtime Regulation

What is the New Overtime Regulation?

frustrated workerOn December 1, 2016, the Labor Department will officially institute new regulations on overtime eligibility for workers. Announced on May 17, the new rules require business owners to pay salary workers earning up to $47,476 a year time-and-a-half overtime pay when they work more than 40 hours during the week. This new regulation will be updated every three years to adjust for average pay in the United States.

Federal employment law stipulates two different ways for employees to receive overtime pay. First, if the employee is not an executive or a professional with decision-making authority they are eligible. Second, if the salary of an employee is below a certain amount, that employee can receive overtime pay.

Who is Affected?

While the Labor Department calculated that the new law will affect 4.2 million workers, the Economic Policy Institute estimates that this new regulation will affect 12.5 million employees. That is 23% of salaried workers. The institute expects these new rules to affect over one million Texans.

The new overtime rule will apply to any business that is subject to the Fair Labor Standards Act. This includes any business with sales of at least $500,000, or employers involved in interstate commerce. The National Federation of Independent Businesses says that the requirements will affect around 44% of US business with fewer than 500 employees.

History of Overtime Pay Regulations

The 1938 law that began federal minimum wage also started the overtime rule. While the government has raised the overtime pay salary cut-off several times over the years, the current cut-off is at $23,660. Vice President Biden noted that that more than 60 percent of salaried workers qualified for overtime in 1975 based on their salaries, but only 7 percent do today.

Complying with Regulations

To comply with these new regulations, employers will have to track employees work hours, even those of salaried employees. This change can involve costly adjustments as employers may have to buy new systems and spend time on regulatory compliance. Additionally, employers may have to change the way they manage their labor budget. Failure to comply can result in lawsuits or penalties.

Employers will most likely respond in a couple of ways. Some employers will choose to limit their employees’ work hours to avoid paying overtime. Others may hire additional workers and divide up existing jobs. Additionally, employers could raise the pay of employees whose salaries are close to the cutoff to avoid paying overtime work. Or employers could cut salaries of workers with the hope that overtime will make up the difference in income.

Oxford Economics predicted that a “disproportionate number[s] of workers” [that] became eligible for overtime and worked more than 40 hours would see their hourly rates decreased by an equal amount, leaving their total annual earnings unchanged.” On the other hand, the Institute for the Study of Labor, said that base wages would fall somewhat over time, but that the higher overtime payments would more than offset any loss in regular salary levels.

Positive Aspects of the New Regulations

The new regulations could potentially have positive effects on the labor force. Goldman Sachs and the Economic Policy Institute estimate that the new regulations will create about 120,000 jobs.

The main argument, however, it is only right for employees to earn overtime for working over 40 hours. Vice President Biden and other supporters of the change present the idea of fairness as the main positive aspect of the new regulation. The Obama Administration hopes that the rule change will give middle-class families additional income.

Negative Aspects of the New Regulations

Despite the potential for positive effects, the new regulations could bring numerous negative consequences for employers.

The new regulations will immediately require employers to keep track of employee attendance and hours. This tracking will impose implementation and operation expenses, which may be prohibitively high for smaller and less profitable firms. Payroll reclassification for small businesses can also be time consuming and expensive. Business owners must also figure out whether their workers are exempt from the new requirements. Misclassification can result in lawsuits and penalties. And, of course, small businesses may face increased payroll expense.

All of these changes can be costly for small businesses to implement. A study by the National Retail Federation estimated employers could end up having to pay as much as $874 million to update payroll systems, convert salaried employees to hourly wages and track their hours. The potential costs have not gone unnoticed; the National Federation of Independent Businesses filed a petition to delay the implementation of these new rules. Otherwise, the new regulation may drive some small firms out of business.

Hurting Workers

This new measure could even hurt employees by giving workers less flexibility, hour cuts and decreased morale. Salaried employees often enjoy flexibility in working hours that can allow them a certain amount of freedom. This flexibility is about to become more expensive as employees are required to record every hour of their work. Being a salaried employee, rather than per-hour labor, also has positive psychological benefits. Employee morale may therefore drop. Finally, employees will soon run the risk that their employers will cut their hours to avoid paying overtime.

Jobs may be created by this regulation. However, most of those new jobs could come from cutting a full-time job in half to avoid paying overtime. Coordinating two people to do one person’s job will make America’s workforce less productive.

Room for Improvement

These new regulations disproportionately hurt small businesses. It may be important to respect the rights of workers to earn more money for overtime. However, the government must find a solution to help low-income workers without imposing a burden on small business owners.

A step in the right direction would be to institute this new regulation in phases. The overtime income cutoff change from $23,660 to $47,476 is a huge difference. But unless government offsets these costs, perhaps by lowering taxes on small businesses, this new policy will discriminate against the 28 million small businesses that provide more than 8 million American jobs.

Categories
McNair Center Weekly Roundup

Entrepreneurship Weekly Roundup: 10/28/2016

 Weekly Roundup is a McNair Center series compiling and summarizing the week’s most important Innovation and Entrepreneurship news.

Here is what you need to know about entrepreneurship this week:

Big Problems for Small Practices

Catherine Kirby, Research Assistant, McNair Center for Entrepreneurship and Innovation

Kirby examines the effects of the Affordable Care Act on entrepreneurship within health care. U.S. health care regulations currently hinder entrepreneurship among healthcare professionals, particularly for doctors seeking to establish private practices.
Kirby recommends that the U.S. implement policy changes that would better foster entrepreneurship among physicians. Measures like restructuring reimbursement rates and improving quality of care requirements would reduce the burdens that many private practices face and enable physicians to start small medical practices.

U.S. early stage investment holds up, late stage plunges

Joanna Glasner and Gené Teare, Contributors, CrunchBase

Venture capital investment slowed in the third quarter. Glasner and Teare write that estimates relying on end-of-quarter data may overstate declines in early stage investment.
Crunchbase compares its own projected funding totals with reported round count totals for the third quarter. Quarterly projected funds show bullish early stage investment. When factoring in projections, Crunchbase’s report for the third quarter finds that U.S. startups continue to enjoy high levels of strategic, seed and venture capital investment during seed and early stage rounds. However, there is a steep decline in late stage investment, with fewer companies raising late stage rounds and investors pouring less money into Series C and later rounds.

Startups get bought not sold

Ken Elefant, managing director at Intel Capital, PE Hub

Many entrepreneurs focus, sometimes shortsightedly, on the dream of reaching an IPO. As a result, start-ups often fail to develop important relationships with corporate investors. According to data from Dealogic, only five U.S.-based tech companies went public in the first eight months of 2016. To avoid going out of business or selling at a fire-sale price, Elefant recommends that entrepreneurs develop strong relationships with corporate investors early on so that a later search for an acquisition offer does not turn into a last-ditch attempt to save a sinking ship.
Corporate investors invest in companies for three reasons: to gain access to a technology, to break into other markets and to acquire. For start-ups, relationships with corporate investors offer viability and credibility. Additionally, these relationships provide development, support,  feedback and access to corporate engagement and funds. For companies that might not be on track for an IPO, strong relationships with corporate investors can lay the groundwork for an acquisition.

‘Shark Tank for Students’ Re-Defines Entrepreneurship

Christopher Putvinski, SAPVoice, Forbes

Putvinski focuses on a new television series, The Social Innovation Series. This “Shark Tank or a Y Combinator for students” asks aspiring entrepreneurs to address problems in health or wellness in their own communities.
The show grants $1,000 to students with promising and innovative ideas and a grand prize of $10,000 and the title of “SAP Teen Innovator” to the student with the winning idea.

How Blind Hiring Can Make Your Company More Inclusive

Frida Polli, Mattermark


In an editorial for Mattermark, Polli writes on how diverse companies outperform their non-diverse counterparts. Increasing diversity among employees not only promotes a more fair and equitable workplace environment but also offers a high return on investment for companies. See the McKinsey & Company Report on how diversity improves company performance. Polli suggests that “blind auditioning” is a possible solution for the lack of diversity in companies’ workforces. Using advanced analytics and assessment technologies, companies can ensure predictability and eliminate bias in their pre-hiring assessments of applicants. According to Polli, “improving diversity isn’t just the right thing to do, it’s the smart thing to do.”

And in startup news…

Google buys eye-tracking VR firm Eyelock

Grant Gross, Senior Editor for IDG News Service

Eyefluence is a California-based startup focused on eye-interaction technologies in Virtual Reality (VR) and Augmented Reality (AR) headsets. Serial entrepreneurs Jim Marggraff and David Stiehr founded Eyefluence in 2013.
Google acquired the startup on Tuesday. The acquisition reflects Google’s growing interest in VR and AR technology. The deal further shows the growing potential of VR and AR for entrepreneurs interested in building successful tech startups.

Wavefront gathers $52 mil Series B

Iris Dorbian, Author, PE Hub

Another California-based tech-based startup, Wavefront, recently reported raising $52 billion in Series B funding. Investors include big names such as Sequoia Capital, Sutter Hill Ventures and Tenaya Capital.
Wavefront develops metrics monitoring services for cloud and modern application environments. Wavefront offers invaluable services to leaders in the software industry that rely on Cloud technology, such as Workday, Box, Lyft, Microsoft, Intuit and Groupon.

Categories
McNair Center Small Business

Immigrants and Entrepreneurship

Embracing Immigrant Entrepreneurs

Every day Sharan Gahunia, owner of Raja Sweets in the Hillcroft area of Houston, Texas, sells mithai and other Indian pastries in the shop her father founded over 30 years ago. When Raja Sweets first opened up, there was little South Asian cuisine and culture within Houston, but through hard work and entrepreneurship, South Asian immigrants like Gahunia have helped turn the Hillcroft area into a booming cultural center officially recognized as the Mahatma Gandhi district.

Immigrant entrepreneurs like the Gahunia family are a key factor in American small business and entrepreneurship. 

Where are Immigrant Entrepreneurs from?

Immigrant entrepreneurs are a diverse and growing group. According to statistics from the 2013 American Community Survey, the vast majority of immigrant business owners, 23.4%, originate from Mexico, reflecting the large and long-standing Mexican immigrant population in the United States. The next three countries of origin in terms of raw number of business owners are Korea with 5.1% and India and Vietnam with Houston's Chinatown is home to many immigrant-run small businesses. https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:MetropoleCenterHoustonTX.jpg4.1% each.

Examining the percentage of business owners by country of origin provides further insight. Iran appears to be the largest exporter of entrepreneurs, with nearly 1/4, or 24.4%, of Iranian immigrants in the U.S. owning a business. The next three countries of origin with the highest rates of business ownership are South Korea with 23.1%, Brazil with 21.0% and Italy with 20.1%.

Educational Extremes and Type of Work

The survey also shows that the distribution of educational degrees among immigrant entrepreneurs is statistically bimodal. 29.8% of immigrant business owners possess a college degree, yet 25.7% of them, the second largest portion, do not have a high school degree. This wide range of educational backgrounds may reflect differences in the immigrant entrepreneur’s countries of origin.

Immigrant entrepreneurs tend to live in the larger states, with 27.8% in California, 11.8% in Florida, 10.7% in New York and 10.5% in Texas. Most immigrant entrepreneurs own either construction or professional service firms, representing 17.2% and 16.7% of all immigrant owned small businesses, respectively. However, the type of work immigrant entrepreneurs engage in is diverse, ranging from agriculture to wind-power generation. A surprising 16.2% of all immigrant owned business fall into the impossible to categorize category “other.”

Small Business Entrepreneurs

In 2012 the Small Business Administration reported higher rates in business ownership and business formation among the U.S. immigrant population as compared to the non-immigrant population. The SBA further found that immigrant-owned businesses tend to export to the global market at a disproportionately higher rate as well.

In 2014, the Kauffman Foundation found that the percentage of small businesses owned by immigrants more than doubled from 13.3 % in 1996 to 28.5% in 2014. The foundation also showed that immigrants did as well or better than native-born entrepreneurs with “opportunity entrepreneurship.” Immigrants are skilled at finding and filling market gaps — such as the unmet demand for Indian pastries the Gahunia family exploited.

Research even suggests that immigrant entrepreneurs perform better as compared to non-immigrant entrepreneurs. In a 2015 study, economists Robert Fairlie and Magnus Lofstrom found that immigrants were well suited to entrepreneurship. They listed ties with already existing immigrant populations, high amounts of family savings, and a lack of pre-existing career, as factors the may make immigrant entrepreneurs particularly successful.

High-technology Entrepreneurship

In the world of high-technology, high growth entrepreneurship, the National Venture Capital Association (NVCA) reported that, “If immigrant-founded venture-backed public companies were a country, then the value of its stock exchange would rank 16th in the world, higher than the exchanges of Russia, South Africa and Taiwan.”  These trends hold for privately held venture-backed companies as well. The study found that immigrant entrepreneurs started 30% of these businesses.

Even outside of high-growth start-up firms, immigrants have a strong positive impact in high-technology. For example, the University of Michigan showed that total computer science employment would have been 3.8% between 9.0% lower if immigration were held at 1994 levels.

 

Looking toward the Future

The NVCA study reported that 78% of immigrant entrepreneurs started their business while either on an H1B employer-sponsored or a F-1 international student visa. Overall, there is strong evidence that immigrants perform better as entrepreneurs than native-born individuals and that they are a boon to the U.S. economy. Reforming immigration policy to encourage yet more immigrant entrepreneurs would therefore contribute to America’s prosperity in the 21st century.